Non classé

fostex t50rp mk3

By 8 December 2020 No Comments

The Fostex RPmk3 series headphones are successors to the reputed RPmk2 series, which for more than 30 years (including from the start of the T-series) have been used as reliable monitor headphones by professional recording studios across the globe. Fostex 6301B was the company's most small powered monitor speaker for broadcast and professional use. (DIYers will often add putty or epoxy to the inside of the housing to stiffen it and reduce stray vibration.) These headphones really shine in all frequency ranges and the more complex the music is; the more you’ll be able to experience the full scope of their capabilities. £136 Add to Basket: 11% bought beyerdynamic DT-770 Pro 80 Ohms: £105: 9% bought AKG K-371: £99: 9% bought beyerdynamic DT-990 Pro: But the Mk3 looks to me like a bit more sophisticated acoustic circuit than the simple hole of the Mk2. Head-Fi T50RP modification index. Resources But often it will persist as an intermittent connection, cutting in and out seemingly at will or, amazingly, randomly lowering the volume in one ear. The low frequencies of the Fostex T60RP vs … Fostex T50RP mk3. The T20RP Mk3 is advertised as the "open" model; the filter over the opening is very thin and permeable. These cover holes that exit into the space sandwiched between the front and back parts of the baffle plate. The Fostex T50RP MK3 headphones are a nice mixture of value for money and performance that you’ll enjoy if you’re a professional or amateur. Fostex T50-RP MK3 Overview Styled in a semi-open design, the RPmk3 Series T50RPmk3 from Fostex comprises a pair of stereo headphones. Editor’s Rating: 4.6/5. I replaced mine with Brainwavz Replacement Angled Memory Foam Earpad - Black - Suitable For Large Over The Ear Headphones - AKG, HifiMan, ATH, Philips, Fostex … The only difference I was able to see between all three models on visual inspection was the density of the paper filter over the vent to the outside of the capsule housing. Product Description. The bad news is that Fostex did not change the locking jack on the left ear piece. Fortunately, the headphones are quite easy to disassemble, and jack replacement—or jackless connection by soldering the cable directly to the driver terminals—is fairly straightforward. However, this is not a headphone that will gain wide popularity for three important reasons: If you are not a hard-core headphone enthusiast interested in modifying headphones, you'll likely be better served by the Audio Technical ATH-M50x, which is fully sealed, about the same price, has better bass response, and is likely nearly as durable. (Circled in red in the above photo.) €133.62. I also use a Schiit LOKI Mini graphic equalizer to tailor the sound of the T50 to … The Fostex T50RP MK3 marks a tour de force in the company’s headphones and is a substantial improvement over its predecessor series. I have a pair of Fostex T50RP MK 3 headphones and find that they work well with several of my headphone amplifiers. Fostex T50RP-Mk3 Headphone. did a comparaison side by side with dt880 pro, akg 701, yamaha hph mt7w,audio technica ath-m50x. SGD $294. The original pancake pads are complete and utter poo poo. Profesjonalne słuchawki studyjne. RM 760.00. (How can it even do that!?) Profesjonalne słuchawki studyjne. FREE Shipping by Amazon. Hello I am a complete newbie to the HiFi world. But they've also found a home with headphone enthusiasts as they respond very well to modifications. In the above and following pictures, the older version of the T50RP will be on the left, the new Mk3 version on the right. To my ears, the T50RP Mk3 is a much better sounding headphone than its predecessor. You. The Fostex T50RP is part of the MK3 series, the successor of the critically acclaimed RPmk2 series that enjoyed rave reviews from producers and engineers alike. III - Version 1. for T20RPmk2/mk3, T40RPmk2/mk3 and T50RP/mk3. I think it may be possible, if one so chooses, to simply transplant the baffle plate from a new Mk3 model into the housing of a modified Mk2 housing. New (2) from ₹ 51,249.00 + FREE Shipping. The Fostex T50RP, with its potential to sound truly fantastic with simple modifications, has exploded in popularity in recent years. Rated 5 out of 5 by Amarulagold from Budget audiophile headphones that need a lot of power (and better cables) Quite possibly the absolute best value for money headphones if you want a planar magnetic pair of cans. HIFIMAN HE400i has 93 dB, while Fostex T50RP MK3 has 92 dB. More importantly, the Fostex T50RP MK3 manages the difficult task of achieving robustness and durability without sacrificing compactness and lightness. This jack is reliably unreliable. Here's a picture of just the capsule housing. In the T50RP modding thread there are numerous accounts of changing the density and configuration of this filter. The gentle rise from 400Hz to 2kHz of the Mk3 is highly desirable, in my opinion, and is quite similar to the Harman Target Response. Inside the T40RP and T20 RP Mk3 Models On top of its light and compact build, the Fostex T50RP MK3 doesn’t clamp too tightly on your head and its headband is very well padded and soft. The 1.2m mini plug cable that comes with the package is very compact and flexible and doesn’t have the tendency to get tangled up. Begin Incremental Mods and Measurements A. Fostex T50RP - All Stock Left Side: Current production with smooth finished metal hangers and non-textured, translucent white driver dampener 1. $161. It consists of 4 models: the T20RP mk3, T40RP mk3, T50RP mk3 and T60RP (note no mk3 designation as this is the first T60 model but it does utilize the mk3 … 5 customers have given this product a 5-star rating. Fostex T50-RP MK3 Overview Styled in a semi-open design, the RPmk3 Series T50RPmk3 from Fostex comprises a pair of stereo headphones. 5 Customers . 1-16 of 97 results for "fostex t50rp mk3" Fostex T50RP MK3 Professional Studio Headphones, Semi-Open. $159.99. But I still think you should check out the Audio Technica ATH-M50x as a slightly better sounding (mostly in having better bass response) and sealed alternative. This good frequency response is responsible for creating a neutral sound that makes these headphones ideal for a wide variety of music ranging from bass-heavy to vocal-oriented. Compared to the traditional style of headphones, the sound that you get from the Fostex T50RP MK3 is more precise, vibrant, and has a wider range. A good chunk of it tends to be pure marketing hype that offers little when it comes to tangible value while other features are important innovations that you need to have a baseline understanding of. Dac/amp for t50rp mk3 spoiler nsfw Hi there...I need a help to decide which one of these can drive foxter t50rp mk3 (Audio-GD NFB11 or JDS Labs Element or Fostex Hp-A4BL) and if all can drive it which one … Below is a comprehensive Fostex T50RP MK3 review that introduces you to the main features of this pair and makes the case for why they’re worth every penny. The low repulsion ear pads appear to be thinner than average, but they still feel smooth to the ears and offer plenty of cushioning while leaving ample room for them to breathe and not get too hot during prolonged wearing. Speakers Alpha Prime—a heavily modified T50RP Mk2. This region of sound is often fatiguing for people, and T50RP mods are infamous for having peaks in this area. The low frequencies of the Fostex T60RP vs T50RP MK3 have a thick, full, and solid sound. Fostex Black/Orange T50RP MK3 Professional Semi-Open Headphones, 6.35mm Jack + 3.5mm Mini Jack, 92dB, 15hZ - 35kHz is rated 4.5 out of 5 by 2. Watch. They lack sub-bass. FZJZ. They're about the same size and feel, which means that they are a bit thin and can get uncomfortable in long listening...especially if you wear glasses. 4. Need more confirmation? The Fostex T50RP MK3 delivers a rich balanced sound and all the frequencies are reproduced relatively equally. The comfort … This brings both good and bad. The treble is very detailed and transparent, it picks up all the little nuances. There are even a few companies that commercially produce modified versions of this Fostex headphone. Thanks, Dan! The bass is quite impactful and manages to maintain its punch even at lower volumes. III - Version 3 (Bass Model) $264.99 Quick View Fostex T50RP - Mk3 Modding Service. ET-RP1.2, RPmk3 Replacement Cable 1.2m. In 1978, Fostex started to develop speakers for professional use, becoming very well known in both consumer hi-fi and professional fields. The ZMF Classic. Of these, 4 customers have written no texts or given their feedback in another language. 1070 . Mobster. Pair of optional short, flexible cables that enables the Fostex TM2 to connect with In-Ear Monitors (IEM) using 2-Pin Connectors (0.78mm pin diameter) Cable Spec *4N Class Oxygen-Free Copper ... T40RPmk2/mk3 and T50RP/mk3. Fostex T50RP Mk. 7 Days Replacement Available from these sellers. Fostex T50RP MK3 Professional Studio Headphones, Semi-Open. Fostex has imposed itself as one of the industry leaders when it comes to professional audio gear. We all know how hard to drive the mk3's are, but hypothetically speaking if there was a cheap amp/dac that could reliably drive the mk3's, and the hd600's, what would you buy? Fostex T 50 RP mk3 Prof. RP-HEADPHONES, 15hz - 35khz, Semi-open T 50 RPmk 3 Differences Between the T50RP Mk2 and T50RP Mk3. III V.1 These are my second Mayflower/Fostex purchase, still using and enjoying my originals, reports of good improvements without degradation gave me cause to add these to the shop. The new T50RP Mk3 is, to my ears, much better sounding than its predecessor, delivering excellent tonal balance and good clarity. $13.65 shipping. The ear cups are extremely solid and have shown complete flexibility when adjusted both vertically and horizontally. I am planning on getting a pair of T50RP MkIII and Mod them if I didnt like how they sounded as stock. View on Amazon. confort is good but could be improve, and actually there is a lot of mod possible on these cans. https://www.amazon.com/fostex-t50rp-mk3/s?k=fostex+t50rp+mk3 The dip at around 6kHz, and peak around 10kHz on both Fostex models are not desirable, and likely contribute to the slight sizzle of the Mk3 model in the treble. Fostex T50RP mk III Modded Build - New Cups, Cable, the works! IMO t50rp is not best choice when we come to gaming. Buy on Amazon Mids are strong here they don't sit forward or anything but the way … The 20 is on the left, and 40 on the right in each photo. The new pad also uses a slightly different type of foam internally. FOSTEX T50RP MK3. Also Our site participates in other associates programs beside amazon. They are realistic sounding and many will find them unimpressive for gaming. Fostex claims the drivers themselves are identical but, as you can see, the filter paper on the back of the driver is different. The stock earpads of the t50rp mk3 are pretty awful unless you're into on-ears, and even then they're average at best. While most headphones in its price bracket tend to lose half of their frequency range when plugged directly into a device, this pair retains most of its capabilities and manages to deliver high-quality sound even at very high volumes. USA Distributor: American Sound and Music, original, but fairly different, Fostex T50, Koss PRO-4, PRO-4A and Pro/4 AAA Plus headphones, Shure Bluetooth 5.0 Earphone Communication Cable, Shure KSE1200SYS electrostatic in-ear headphone system, Skullcandy Crusher Wireless Over-Ear Sealed Headphones with Haptic Bass Drivers, HiFiMAN Sundara Around-Ear Open Planar Magnetic Headphones, PSB M4U 8 Over-Ear Wireless Noise Canceling Headphones, Audeze LCD2 Classic Open Over-Ear Planar Magnetic Headphones, Advanced Alpha Over-Ear Open Planar Magnetic Headphones, Beyerdynamic DT 240 Pro Affordable Over-Ear Sealed Headphones, Sennheiser HD 660 S Over-Ear Open Headphones, Gramophone Dreams #43: First Watt F8 power amplifier, Bowers & Wilkins 705 Signature loudspeaker, Analog Corner #304: SAT XD1 record player, Acoustic Geometry Room treatments (before & after), My current and likely the last home audio setup, Fascinating wiev by Verity Audio Sarastro, Recommended Components: Fall 2020 Edition. (Enigmatic Audio; ZMF Headphones; Mr. Professionals and everyday users can benefit greatly from this fact and get the most value for their money. The midrange is what drives a song and contains all its main elements like the vocals and melody, so you’ll be assured to know that the T50RP MK3’s mids are some of the fullest and more transparent that we ever tested. First up is the an unmodded Fostex T50RP mk3 with MrSpeakers Alpha pads. Speakers). The soundstage might be a little bit narrow, but the sound quality more than makes up for it, especially for the price point. The original pancake pads are complete and utter poo poo. If you liked the T50RP Mk2 then, you'll probably like the Mk3 model even more now. HIFIMAN HE400i has 93 dB, while Fostex T50RP MK3 has 92 dB. But just as it is the case in a dynamic system, electrical current flows through the thin wires of the diaphragm which converts the electronic source into audio. As it is the case with most headphones that are targeted at audio professionals and not young people looking to make a fashion statement or hop on a new fad, the Fostex T50RP MK3 are priced in a way that reflects their actual quality and doesn’t factor in the marketing hype that drives most popular brands. Fostex Premium Stereo Headphones with Tesla Magnetic Circuit, Black/Walnut (TH-610) This scuffing pattern is the same on both housings which leads me to believe both parts came out of the same mold and are identical. This pair is equipped with Fostex proprietary RP diaphragm driver and boasts a copper foil etched polyimide film and a very potent neodymium magnet. The trade-off, I suspect, is that diaphragm damping is reduced and may increase resonances and cause treble response problems. I will link to T50RP threads in the "Resources" section at the end of the article, which delve into the various replacement pads and how users perceive performance changes. But in a time where manufacturers are trying to outdo each other in seeing who can come up with the flashiest, more colorful, and futuristic looking headphones, the old school vibe that the T50RP MK3 exudes is a breath of fresh air in a rather stale market. Dac/amp for t50rp mk3 spoiler nsfw Hi there...I need a help to decide which one of these can drive foxter t50rp mk3 (Audio-GD NFB11 or JDS Labs Element or Fostex Hp-A4BL) and if all can drive it which one is the best between them in sound quality. Audio-Technica ATH-M50 X. When it comes to frequency response, the first appliance has a range of 20 Hz - 35 kHz, whilst the second one works in a range between 15 … First up is the an unmodded Fostex T50RP mk3 with MrSpeakers Alpha pads. The Mk2 sounded quite mid-emphasized with a rolled off treble and bass response. Other than the fabric screen of the Mk3, the pads are quite similar. Speaking of pads, here's a quick look at them. The RP mk3 Series The current Fostex RP mk3 headphone series was released in 2015 as a successor to the popular mk2 series. And with that, I'll point you towards the various sites and threads about this historic headphone and its modification. Fostex International product pages. 5. 1: 2: 3: Pay Today: 2: 3: Use your debit or credit card Your chosen card will be charged automatically What you see is what you pay No interest, No Admin fee and No Late fee Here is the rear of the baffle plate. Here's the rear of the baffle plate with drivers attached. 4.5 out of 5 stars (19) 19 product ratings - Fostex T50RP MK3 Professional Studio Headphones, Semi-Open. The Mk2 (left) has a permanently attached screen/filter over the driver; the Mk3 has a recessed driver with a foam piece mounted in front. But before I go on, I need to thank Dan Clark at Mr. noise cancelling They are extremely inefficient and cannot reach a solid listening level using most portable players and smartphones. This is a well documented problem in the enthusiast community, and frankly I'm quite disappointed Fostex didn't address it in the product refresh. $159.99 $ 159. When it comes to frequency response, the first appliance has a range of 20 Hz - 35 kHz, whilst the second one works in a range between 15 Hz and 35 kHz. or Best Offer. The driver is differently constructed (damping) and there is a different colour scheme and headband. The current iteration is the Mk3 (excluding the T60RP which is effectively Fostex’s take on their own headphone - metafostex if you will) and fixed many of the issues present in the Mk2 version. Music aficionados and hardcore gamers will appreciate how comfortable these headphones are and how wide and immersive their soundstage is. Fluance SX6W Review – Is This Speaker Deserve Buy? 4.4 out of 5 stars 238. If you’re simply looking for top sound quality at a reasonable price and without the hollow marketing terms and unrelenting salesmanship that comes with most consumer headphones, there are few options that fit the bill more than the Fostex T50RP MK3. If you are a headphone enthusiast who's interested in playing around with headphone modifications, the Fostex T50RP Mk3 is a terrific place to start—or continue—your headphone modifying activities! I would'nt call the fostex a good portable headphone, however. Another popular pad swap is for the Shure 1540 pads … Here are some close-ups of the driver itself. The Fostex T50RP mk3 is an improved version of the T50RP (mk2). Fostex T50RP Mk. The T50RP is a popular studio headphone for modders, with techniques ranging from pad swapping to mass loading to balancing. What the graphs do not show, however, is the resonance and standing waves heard from Stock T50RP's and described throughout the main T50RP mod forum. The more similar T50RP however, first introduced in 2002, bears a strong family resemblance. the fostex driver naturally starts to roll off around 10khz. Fostex T50RP MK3. it is perfectly normal and sounds fine. The Mk3 sounds much better balanced, erring mainly with a very slight sizzle in the treble, and loss of bass below around 100Hz. -Nad HP50: As good as it is at being portable, it costs twice as much and it is bested in all convievable areas by the T50RP MK3. The treble is very detailed and transparent, it picks up all the little nuances. Budowa pół otwarta, dla wiernej reprodukcji czystego dźwięku. The T50RP is considered "semi-open" and has a filter with permeability somewhere between the other two. You can expect to get detailed and layered sound when you plug this pair into any portable music player or mobile device. Best Budget: Fostex T50RP MK3. Discussion in 'Sound City' started by stoke1863, 22 Mar 2016. Fostex was then established in June 1973 to brand components manufactured by Foster Electric. The adjusters are made out of top grade aluminum and the wires out of copper, providing them with resistance to corrosion and wear. You can see in the photo above that the two versions remain quite similar looking. Show only OP | 22 Mar 2016 at 23:24 #1. stoke1863. This is an important observation, as we'll soon see, because the air-gap between the baffle plate and capsule housing serves as an acoustically tuned vent. So, we modified the mk3 drivers to eliminate this peak. If you're a DIYer with a measurement rig, take care to note exactly what this area looks like on your measurements (they may look quite different than mine on a non-IEC-spec measurement system), and try to retain the profile between 400Hz and 2kHz during your mods. Moultrie A5 Low Glow Camera Review – [Pros & Cons], Sennheiser IE80 Headphone Review – Our Honest Review, Input that reaches 3000mW to suit different studios uses, Includes a 3m 1/4-inch plug detachable cable and 1.2m mini plug cable, New planar magnetic drivers for a more concise sound, Neutral sound with all frequencies presented in the same amplitude, Well padded headband for reduced pressure during extended wearing, Provides planar magnetic technology at an affordable price, Offers great portability for a pair that is primarily designed for studio use, Doesn’t require an amplifier to perform adequately, The power requirement of these headphones is a bit on the higher side. Subscribe via Email. I would say fully half of all T50RPs I've had here in the lab have displayed some sort of intermittent connection while in use. Here's an edge-on photo of the baffle plates. The Fostex T50RP mk3 Studio Headphones includes free shipping to Singapore at the best price of SGD $294. This vent does not exist in the same way on the Mk3. On the Mk3 baffle plate you can see to sections of filter paper at the top and bottom of the plate. 7. Only 15 left in stock (more on the way). Joined: 13 Jun 2009 Posts: 4,562 Location: Chesterfield. it provides enough air response. The Mk2 is flatter and better extended than the Mk3, but I very much like a slight measured bass emphasis and much prefer the meatier sound of the Mk3 to the Mk2 even though it's not as well extended. They are extremely different in sound signature; the mk3… My guess is achieving this rise is a tricky combination of a number of things, and may suffer during modifications. €111.21. Fostex is part of the wave of Japanese manufacturers that swept the audio equipment market in the 70’s and 80’s. I suspect DIYers may want to play around with occluding these holes in varying degrees in conjunction with pad selection to control and linearize bass response. Pair of optional short, flexible cables that enables the Fostex TM2 to connect with In-Ear Monitors (IEM) using 2-Pin Connectors (0.78mm pin diameter) Cable Spec *4N Class Oxygen-Free Copper ... T40RPmk2/mk3 and T50RP/mk3. $133. Just to round out this exploration of the mechanical differences between models, here are a series of photos of the T20RP Mk3 and T40RP Mk3. The peak at about 3.5kHz on the Mk3 is maybe 2-3dB too high (there does need to be a peak here on raw measurements), but the other two headphones quite obviously don't have a high enough peak here. Dekoni Audio Blue Fostex… These headphones have long been a staple at recording studios due to their clear rendering of the mid-range, and bullet-proof construction. The result is a very rich and clear sound that enables the listener to detect the various layers of a track that can go unnoticed when wearing cheaper devices. If you are an audio pro accustom to the T50RP Mk2, you will likely find the Mk3 version much better sounding, just as durable, but slightly less efficient than the Mk2 model. Fostex T50RP MK3 Review – Must Read Before Buy, https://www.howtogeek.com/327846/what-are-planar-magnetic-headphones/, http://www.slate.com/blogs/quora/2013/05/03/do_high_quality_headphones_really_make_music_sound_that_much_better.html, https://medium.com/@Xander51/audio-dictionary-warm-vs-neutral-vs-bright-and-the-role-your-brain-plays-in-all-this-2ec761759f7b, https://www.head-fi.org/threads/what-exactly-is-a-neutral-sound-signature.818339/. Utilizing many tuning … In the lower right quadrant of the inside of the housing you can see some scuffing from the mold tool. Q: What is the difference in sound between a mk3 … I have watched and read a lot of reviews … What the graphs do not show, however, is the resonance and standing waves heard from Stock T50RP's and described throughout the main T50RP mod forum. Available immediately. It comes with 2 cables. The fostex mk3's … In a planar magnetic headphone, the sound is created by thin, flexible material that mirrors the electrostatic style. The T40RP Mk3 is "closed" and essentially has a piece of impermeable tape over the hole. The mk3 Argons have less energy between 8-10khz. $289.99 Quick View Fostex T50RP Mk. Since home users and studio professionals can find themselves spending hours wearing their headphones, Fostex has committed to offering a level of comfort that matches the sound quality of their audio devices. They are not remarkably fast, however, sound detailed. for T20RPmk2/mk3, T40RPmk2/mk3 and T50RP/mk3. Their copper foil etched polyimide film drivers utilize proprietary Regular Phase (RP) technology in order to ensure an accurate reproduction of sonic material, thereby rendering these semi-open headphones suitable for monitoring in studio situations. Get the guaranteed best price on Studio Headphones like the Fostex T50RP mk3 Studio Headphones (Semi-Open) at Musician's Friend. Fostex T50RP MK3 Professional Studio Headphones, Semi-Open. Fostex T50RP MK3 Review – High Tech at a Low Price. If you are a headphone enthusiast looking for an entry level open planar magnetic headphone, but are not interested in doing headphone modifications, you'll likely be better served by the HiFiMAN HE400S ($299), which has a somewhat more refined and open sound. They have a semi-open design so you’re getting the best of both worlds – a wide soundstage and decent noise isolation. This region of sound is often fatiguing for people, and T50RP mods are infamous for having peaks in this area. more_vert. It’s generally advisable to use an amplifier when you’re working with a top quality headphone, especially in a studio environment where every little detail matters. Style and design are subjective, so not everyone will agree on what constitutes a nice looking pair of headphones. This article is less product review and more about the T50RP Mk3 and the differences between it and the previous iteration, written specifically to provide some initial information about innards of the model, and to posit about what modifications might be useful. When it comes to using this pair at home, the T50RP MK3 offers a substantial improvement in quality when compared to entry-level products. $159.99. FOSTEX T50RP MK3. Speakers for, on very short notice, sending me a T50RP Mk2 to dissect and compare with the new model in this article. The Fostex T50RP-MK3 Stereo Headphones have been engineered using technically-sound features that enable it to deliver a clear and flat sound. ConsumerEpic.Com © 2020 Our site participates in Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for sites to earn advertising fees by advertising and linking to amazon.com The main advantage of the planar magnetic drivers is their ability to completely eliminate any sort of electronic and audio distortion. Get a low price and free shipping on thousands of items. American Music and Sound. 4.4 out of 5 stars 185 ratings. My understanding is that this is a result of very careful changes to the filter paper behind the driver. Planar magnetic drivers combine elements from the more common dynamic style of headphones and the less common system of electrostatic drivers. Another popular pad swap is for the Shure 1540 pads … People love their bass these days, and the T50RP rolls off significantly below 100Hz. The last little bit of information I'll provide DIYers is a small .pdf booklet containing numerous measurements of the T50RP over time and measurements of DIY modified headphones based on the Fostex model. If I were modding the Mk3, I might try to reduce the filter resistance of the baffle plate vents from the rear chamber to slightly reduce the bass emphasis at 100Hz, and then try to extend and reinforce the bass with better pads to get a similar response to the Alpha Prime. You can see the small vent hole of the Mk2 just to the right of the bottom corner of the driver mounting square.

Neuro Ophthalmologist Bucks County, Data Management Pdf, Hebrews 13:4 Esv, Cable Knit Throw Pattern, Manmad To Aurangabad Distance, Angry Cheetah Sound, C+ 3164 Name, Engineering Degree Apprenticeships,

% Comments